Two abstract figures facing each other with colorful symbols and words representing 'Body-Mind,' 'Temple,' and 'Source' on their silhouettes, against a vibrant swirling background.

There’s a prob­lem I see with most neo­pa­gans and mod­ern prac­ti­tion­ers….

First of all, let’s be real. There IS some­thing to some of the claims prac­ti­tion­ers make. One of the most fas­ci­nat­ing things I’ve found about the mag­ick I prac­tice is that it’s usu­al­ly traces about 90% of all the same lines as sci­en­tif­i­cal­ly backed psy­chol­o­gy. You don’t even have to go too far into the transper­son­al realm for most of it. Spir­i­tu­al psy­chol­o­gy, exis­ten­tial psy­chol­o­gy, and human­is­tic psy­chol­o­gy are all look­ing at things humans have been doing for for­ev­er to see why they help us lead more ful­fill­ing lives.

Med­i­ta­tion is good for you, even if it takes the form of a guid­ed jour­ney to meet your guardians, spir­its, ances­tors, gods or high­er pow­ers. Keep­ing a phys­i­cal metaphor of your inten­tion on your per­son to remind you of your objec­tive can help you focus whether you call that a charm or a psy­cho­log­i­cal foci. Your uncon­scious mind can be influ­enced with visualizations—whether you call it affir­ma­tions or glam­ours; by repetition—whether you call them mot­tos, slo­gans, or mantras; or by intense focus on your desires—whether you call that auto­sug­ges­tion or man­i­fes­ta­tion.

Parts work in psy­chol­o­gy is SO much like shad­ow work that the first time I did the lat­ter my shad­ow was already well devel­oped and already wait­ing to talk to me. Habit stack­ing is use­ful to add things you want to do as a dai­ly rou­tine even if you call it rit­u­al prac­tice. Jour­nal­ing helps you think straight and keep track of your long-term thought arcs whether you’re doing it as an intel­lec­tu­al exer­cise or a spir­i­tu­al prac­tice. Time in nature is ground­ing and reju­ve­nat­ing to most humans whether or not you hug a sin­gle tree. High­er pow­ers and pur­pos­es don’t nec­es­sar­i­ly need to be sen­tient beings to give our lives mean­ing and pur­pose. Ser­vice gives us emo­tion­al resilience whether we do it as a call­ing or sim­ply because we see the need to reach out and bridge the divides that wound the human fam­i­ly.

Yes, you can trans­form into a bet­ter ver­sion of your­self if you believe in your­self and are con­fi­dent. And con­fi­dence affects every­thing from per­for­mance to men­tal health to body image and the ener­gy you exude that peo­ple find com­pelling. It does­n’t mat­ter if that is com­ing from pos­i­tive self talk into a mir­ror or a spell to “bring out your inner light.” And it does­n’t mat­ter if your “reminder” that you are awe­some is hooked to some music or a scent or some­thing wrapped around your neck that gets in your way, repeat­ed­ly nudg­ing those thoughts (or “ener­gies”) to the fore­front of your mind.

Code switch­ing into “Skep­ti­cal™” is entire­ly too easy with most of spir­i­tu­al prac­tice.

Now…I’ll admit that ten per­cent that goes towards the woo…I can’t explain and have stopped try­ing. I’ve had expe­ri­ences I don’t claim to understand—I have seen things I can’t explain, I have walked around feel­ing like I was being yanked like a pup­pet when doc­tors said I should be in a coma, I have expe­ri­enced zero pain dur­ing the worst parts of pro­ce­dures as a patron deity declared “You’ve been through enough for a while,” I’ve chan­nelled things that VERY clear­ly were not me and that then made pre­dic­tions about the future that turned out to be SPOT on accu­rate, I’ve learned about things in dreams (from said deity) that turned out to be pre­cise­ly the rit­u­als of a prac­tice I’d nev­er heard of, and I’ve expe­ri­enced a num­ber of coin­ci­dences so large as to give even my skep­ti­cism pause that I’m start­ing to sound ridicu­lous to try to explain it away. But if ratio­nal­iza­tions that sound like “light­ning reflect­ing off of a swamp gas wreathed Venus” help you sleep at night know­ing the world has no mys­ter­ies, won­der­ful. And if my drug addled visions of a sto­ry that has some­how been told enough times that it forms a neur­al net of humans until it becomes sentient—conscious of itself and its puri­ty and it’s tellers, draws pow­ers from humans’ belief, and can influ­ence human­i­ty… Well, if THAT is what helps you sleep at night, won­der­ful.

What­ev­er.

It is in that 90 per­cent that leans towards the “mun­dane” side that I see big prob­lems among mod­ern prac­ti­tion­ers though—problems that trace the lines of the rest of our cul­ture and its pro­cliv­i­ty to silence the voic­es of the pow­er­less. These “mas­ters of tran­scend­ing human lim­i­ta­tions” for­get what the rest of a human being is.

Yes, your per­cep­tion can affect your reality—that’s not real­ly even a note­wor­thy obser­va­tion these days (the sci­ence done on how our brain begins to trick us dur­ing hunger, sleep depri­va­tion, the influ­ence of music, or even the abil­i­ty to solve a math prob­lem that dis­agreed with one’s pol­i­tics)—but to fun­da­men­tal­ly change per­cep­tions in a way that alters our real­i­ty for longer than the song with the eight­ies pow­er chords is on, some­one has to CREATE that prac­tice and do the work and it takes time and ener­gy and prob­a­bly won’t work tomor­row. So you do it for your­self and teach if asked. But what you DON’T do is spew it AT oth­ers like a cere­al box plat­i­tude of weaponized tox­ic pos­i­tiv­i­ty. (“If you’d just see this as a good thing….”) A grat­i­tude prac­tice isn’t going to polyana some­one through chron­ic illness…injury…systematic injustice….or even just a REALLY bad time in their life.

Fuck absolute­ly all the way off with that shit! Let peo­ple tell you they’re hurt­ing. Hear them with­out try­ing to guilt them that their mag­ick ought to be pow­er­ful enough to over­come any hard­ship.

A prac­ti­tion­er who is seri­ous about mag­ick will work to cre­ate a world where those things do not lim­it the range of ALL our poten­tials, not cas­ti­gate those who have obsta­cles to over­come for “bring­ing down the vibes, man.” A true heal­er knows the world is caus­tic and has some empa­thy about that. A true heal­er does­n’t try to claim that an inabil­i­ty to reframe means a wound is actu­al­ly kind of self-inflict­ed.

I feel like the live, laugh, love prac­ti­tion­ers aren’t look­ing around and notic­ing that they’re start­ing on third base by being mid­dle class (usu­al­ly upper­ly so) and most­ly white, and are using their mag­ick and “inten­tions” to jus­ti­fy silence…and silenc­ING oth­ers. In a chill­ing echo to the lack of empa­thy we find every­where in cap­i­tal­ism, they sim­ply wrap it in a mag­i­cal lan­guage “skin” and keep doing what the rest of soci­ety is also doing. But the shad­ows can’t be denied in mag­ick. (Actu­al­ly “ESPECIALLY in mag­ick”) And so try­ing to keep every­thing pos­i­tive always is just more of the same social hier­ar­chy crap and “isms” and “pho­bias” as ever. It’s gate­keep­ing with woo. It’s just dressed up in robes and talk­ing about ascend­ing to the fifth circle….or some­thing.

It’s bull­shit. And of all peo­ple, we ought to know bet­ter than to deny the whole soul.

One response to “The Weaponization of Magick in Toxic Positivity”

  1. Per­haps the “Just World Fal­la­cy” (JWF) relates to this. If I were active­ly hos­tile to the 10%, I would put effort into the usu­al meth­ods of deny­ing it, and that might dam­age my prac­tice of the 90%, right? There’s a some­what sim­i­lar neg­a­tive effect, if I were so deeply invest­ed in the JWF, that I prac­ticed a sim­i­lar hos­til­i­ty to evi­dence con­tra­dict­ing JWF. I would deny both my mun­dane AND my spir­i­tu­al obser­va­tions of injus­tice, and I would react with hos­til­i­ty to any­one whose lived expe­ri­ence was incon­sis­tent with JWF. I could nei­ther men­tor them well, nor learn from them well.
    -
    Zeus favors those who wel­come the guest-stranger. My nation is prob­a­bly not in good stand­ing with Zeus, on how well my nation treats refugees from oth­er nations. So if I plan to con­tact Zeus, then maybe I’d bet­ter start with some pro­pi­ti­a­tions. Same with Y‑h, for that mat­ter!

Leave a Reply

Author

Chris Cookie Avatar

Written by

I NEED YOUR HELP!

These cookies don't bake themselves!

Do you enjoy this blog? Do you think it's worth 10 cents a day? Do you want to see more and better articles, and for me not to have to be fifteen side-gigs in a trench coat? Want to keep this space ad free and never behind a paywall?

As little as a THREE dollars a month will get you votes in patron-only polls, backchannel chats with other patrons, my ear when it comes to future projects, and access to the monthly newsletter—a behind-the-scenes look at what's going on. And of course, you will be supporting my ongoing writing efforts.

Categories

Trending

Discover more from The Cookie Crumbles

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading